First Words of Safe Mars Landing – Tango Delta Nominal

10:32 p.m. on the evening of Aug. 5 was turning out to be one long minute for Steve Sell. Of
course, the previous six had been significantly protracted as well. When added together, the
entry, descent and landing of NASA’s Curiosity Mars rover had been touted as “Seven Minutes
of Terror,” and as far as Sell was concerned things were trending in that direction. What the 42-
year-old engineer from Gettysburg, Pa., wanted more than anything in that seventh minute was
to hear the words “UHF strong.”

There had been a debate amongst Curiosity’s entry, descent and landing team about what their
first words to indicate that the rover had reached the surface should be. The EDL team at
NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory knew their microphones would be “hot” and that NASA TV
was beaming the landing event out live to anybody with the desire and wherewithal to watch.
They also knew that landing safely on Mars meant more than simply landing on Mars — which
any one of the 34 engineers present at JPL’s Building 264 Room 230, also known as the “EDL
War Room,” will tell you at great length is not simple at all. Their rocket-propelled backpack and
rover-lowering Sky Crane system were getting their first all-up test 154 million miles (248
million kilometers) away from home, and there was still plenty that could go wrong even after
the rover was gently placed on the surface…plenty.

What if the descent stage kept descending right on top of the rover? What if the bridles
connecting the two did not separate? What if the algorithm used to throttle up the engines for
the flyaway maneuver was not accurate?

It was the remaining “what ifs” that made what those first words from Mars confirming the
rover was on the surface so important.

“If we said ‘touchdown,’ then people not intimately familiar with EDL might infer that Curiosity
was good to go,” said Sell. “But two more major calls had to be made before I could begin to
breathe again.”

At 10:31:45 p.m. PDT, Jody Davis saw the event record, or EVR, she was looking for appear on
her computer screen in the EDL War Room. She knew that the “Touchdown” EVR would only be
beamed down if the rover’s descent stage had throttled down — a result which could only occur
if the descent stage had offloaded half its weight. The only way the rover could offload half its
weight in an instant is if it were being held up from below.

Davis, a member of the EDL team and an engineer from NASA Langley Research Center in
Virginia, gave the much reviewed, pre-scripted call — “Tango Delta nominal.”

Tango and Delta are phonetic identifiers for T and D, which the team used to represent
touchdown.

One down, two to go, thought Sell. The next call the EDL team was looking for was “RIMU
stable.”

“RIMU stands for Rover Inertial Measurement Unit,” said Sell. “The RIMU gives us the rover’s
orientation as well as any movement it is making. If we landed on a crumbling crater wall or an
unstable sand dune, or were being dragged by a still-connected descent stage across the
surface, then the RIMU would show that in its data set.”

The War Room’s David Way, an engineer from JPL, was monitoring that unit’s performance.
Eight long seconds after Jody’s call, he found the EVR he was looking for.

“RIMU stable,” said Way.

One more crucial milestone to go.

Not receiving that one final call would be something of a long shot to be sure. After all, the
rover was down on the ground, and RIMU indicated it wasn’t moving. Their system had been
proven every step of the way so far. But everyone in the EDL War Room got as far as they did
not only because they were excellent engineers, but because of their predilection for
concocting unappetizing entry, descent and landing scenarios — and then figuring out how to
elude them. And one ton of fuel-laden, rocket-firing descent stage climbing straight up, only to
fall right back down on their factory-fresh landing site and an otherwise good-to-go, roving
Mars laboratory was about as unappetizing a scenario as Sell could imagine.

That final confirmation would not come from Sell’s location. The final confirmation that
Curiosity had landed clean would come 200 yards and one building away from the EDL War
Room. There, in the Mission Support Area of JPL’s Building 230, Adam Steltzner, the mission’s
EDL phase lead, was staring across the room at Brian Schwartz, who was not making eye
contact with anyone. Schwartz, the EDL communications engineer, was staring at his screen. His
task was not to check for a good-news EVR from the rover. Instead, he was waiting to see if the
UHF signal became intermittent, faded away or just cut out altogether — all potential indications that the rover and descent stage had not gone their separate ways.

Eight seconds after the RIMU call — Schwartz looked up.

“UHF strong,” said Schwartz.

With that, Steltzner had all the data he needed. Seated directly in front of the pacing EDL Phase
Lead, Allen Chen felt a jab in the shoulder. Chen, the mission’s “capsule communicator,” knew it could only mean one thing.

“Touchdown confirmed,” said Chen.

Epilogue

With time to reflect upon the events of August 5, Curiosity’s EDL phase lead states only one
thing fazed him that evening.

“The biggest surprise about EDL was there were no surprises,” said Steltzner. “But soon after
we were confirmed down, what I saw on the screen absolutely floored me.”

Months, and even years before landing, Steltzner and his team had kicked around the idea of
imaging the final moments of the descent stage’s short life. Wouldn’t it be cool if the rover’s
first pic could be timed just so?

Working with the surface operations team, they got the timing of the first images from the
surface timed for about 40 seconds after landing — a little bit after the time the descent stage
was estimated to impact the ground after flying away to a safe distance.

“We thought the odds were pretty small that we would see it,” said Steltzner.

But there, right in the upper-middle of those first rear-Hazcam images, was a plume of dust
rising from the surface.

A later image, taken by the High Resolution Imaging Science Experiment camera, or HiRISE,
aboard NASA’s Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter spacecraft in Martian orbit, provides the location
of what Curiosity team members believe is the final destination of the powered descent stage — or Sky Crane — which was programmed to fly away automatically after safely depositing the
rover on the surface.

“With HiRISE we get the Sky Crane’s distance and its compass heading with respect to the
rover,” said Steltzner. “The cloud seen in the distance on the Hazcam images is in perfect
alignment with where we would expect to see the descent stage.

“The inescapable conclusion is that we captured the result of what happens when about 2,200
pounds (1,000 kilograms) of Sky Crane intersect with Martian surface at a pretty good clip. It is
truly an amazing shot on a day full of amazing shots.”

A video of imagery from the rover during EDL, including Adam Steltzner’s commentary, is
available at http://1.usa.gov/NffoWl

Contact:
DC Agle
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, Calif.
+1 818-393-9011
agle@jpl.nasa.gov

More information on NASA’s Curiosity mission:
http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/msl
http://marsprogram.jpl.nasa.gov/msl

Follow the mission on Facebook and Twitter:
http://www.facebook.com/marscuriosity
http://www.twitter.com/marscuriosity