Twin bursts provide several firsts

Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are the most violent explosions in the
Universe, but little is known about them. In recent years, several
theories have been put forward to explain these elusive explosions,
but the mystery still remains. Now, two recent bursts observed by
astronomers at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA)
provide unique data that can not only help test previous models but
also help theorists come up with a better picture of what GRBs really
are.

–A highly polarized blast–

Harvard astronomer David Bersier and his colleagues observed the
first burst, GRB 020405, to measure the amount of polarization of
light from its afterglow. Polarization is a measure of the direction
of vibration of light waves. Polarized light tends to vibrate in a
particular direction in the sky, while unpolarized light vibrates in
all directions equally.

GRB 020405 was observed with the MMT 6.5-meter telescope at Mount
Hopkins, Arizona, on April 6, 2002, a day after the burst was first
detected. Data from this burst indicated a polarization level of
almost 10 percent, the highest level ever measured. A day later, a
second group measured a polarization level of about two percent.
Interestingly, astronomers also observed a two percent polarization
only hours before the 10 percent measurement, implying a rapid change
in polarization on either side of the peak.

Utilizing the MMT was crucial to gathering enough light for the
measurements. The telescope was outfitted with a very sensitive
digital camera and a set of filters used to measure polarization.
These filters are made of the same material used to make polarized
sunglasses.

Said Smithsonian astronomer Brian McLeod, who developed the camera
equipment, “The key to making this measurement was having the camera
installed on the MMT telescope for many different projects. GRBs are
discovered only about once a month, so we can’t just wait around with
the telescope idle. When the GRB went off, we called the astronomers
who happened to be using the telescope that night and asked them to
point the telescope at the GRB.”

GRBs are believed to come from either the merger of two black holes
or neutron stars, or from the explosion of a very massive star.
Models show that these explosions appear very energetic because much
of their energy is blasted outward in two narrow jets in opposite
directions.

In a broad sense, these recent observations support such models,
which predict some amount of varying polarization. But the group’s
observations also demonstrate that many details still need to be
worked out. For instance, polarization from a GRB afterglow is
expected to be highest when viewed from the edge of the jet. In some
cases the polarization can be as high as 20 percent, implying that
GRB 020405 was indeed seen from near the edge of its jet. At this
extreme viewing angle, calculations predict a gradual decrease in
polarization. Instead, the astronomers saw a significant decrease in
the span of just one day.

One by one, the group has ruled out errors resulting from observing
instruments, dust (either in the host galaxy or in the Milky Way),
and microlensing (the temporary brightening in light from a distant
object when a dim star comes between it and the Earth). Bersier hopes
that comparing his results with those of other groups that observed
this burst will help produce a more robust model of GRBs.

–A rapidly varying blast–

If the first burst was rare – as far as viewing angle is concerned –
the second burst was not far behind. Discovered by the orbiting High
Energy Transient Explorer (HETE) satellite on October 4, 2002,
observations of GRB 021004 began less than 10 minutes after the blast.

Bersier and his colleagues wanted to see if the GRB light curve would
show the same short-term variations seen in a burst the previous
year. Sure enough, their observations demonstrated that the light
from the burst fluctuated on a timescale of 15 – 30 minutes. Over the
course of several hours, the brightness of the afterglow repeatedly
decreased and increased. Since several nearby stars did not exhibit
this highly unusual behavior, the team concluded the variations to be
genuine and intrinsic to the burst.

The rapid variations in the light curve, or “wiggles,” are believed
to be due to density variations in the interstellar matter. Since
they appeared within hours of the GRB, astronomers theorize that the
matter must be close to the GRB itself. This is a clue that the
likely source of the GRB was a hypernova, or exploding star.

According to Bersier, “This second burst has provided us with the
best-sampled light curve to date.” The more than 100 data points
revealed a gradually fading burst with a significant bump in the
light curve. This sudden increase in energy while the afterglow was
fading has puzzled astronomers. Though several models can help
explain the surge of energy at the start of the blast and minor
surges in the middle, no single model has been found to explain this
extra energy during fading. Bersier says more detailed work is needed
before a completely accurate model emerges and suggests accounting
for energy distributions in future models.

The rapid brightness fluctuations were not the only thing that caught
astronomers’ interest. Watching this burst, Bersier and his
colleagues were surprised to see the afterglow change its intrinsic
color as it faded. While one other burst has shown a similar color
change, that burst is believed to have been affected by microlensing.
No model can explain the color change seen in GRB 021004 yet.

On a fundamental level, findings from these two bursts will help
answer some basic questions about the Universe. Light from these
bursts began its journey billions of years ago, when the Universe
itself was a teenager. It was the time when clouds of dense gas
combined violently to form new stars and new galaxies. Scientists
hope that by observing the oldest visible phenomenon in the Universe,
they will some day be able to answer how life itself began.

This research was reported within papers in the February 1, 2003, and
February 20, 2003, issues of The Astrophysical Journal Letters.

Headquartered in Cambridge, Massachusetts, the Harvard-Smithsonian
Center for Astrophysics (CfA) is a joint collaboration between the
Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory and the Harvard College
Observatory. CfA scientists organized into six research divisions
study the origin, evolution, and ultimate fate of the universe.